[FFML] [XOver][R.5/Macross] Macross 1/2 Part 6 Chapter 5: Mutiny

Timothy Groves groves_ca at yahoo.co.uk
Wed Oct 31 06:27:15 PDT 2007


skychan wrote:
> God you have to love idots like Lynn Kyle.  Though for the record, it seems
> unlikely that the tomahawk's missles cooking off would destroy it and more
> likely in the case of one of the Spartans or a Galdiator.  This chapter
> seems a bit unfinished.  I think you might want to go through one more time
> to flesh bits out some more.  While I like the mirror assaults I don't know
> that we get quite enough detail on either to make them feel real.  Perhaps a
> bit about who is with each group beyond the commanders earlier.
>   
Hey, I'm a lot nicer to Kyle than Lisa Grey was in Dragon Lady of 
Macross. :)

As to the Tomahawk issue, it matter little whether the explosions of the 
missiles would completely destroy the Mecha. They would, at least, 
remove the arms, probably destroy the linkages required to operate the 
torso gun mount, and certainly wipe out the medium-range missile box. 
Therefore rendering unarmed, and without the ability to fight even in 
hand-to-hand. The crew are probably fine, but it's out of the fight.

And I note the typical confusion with Macross vs Robotech Destroid 
naming; 'Spartans' in Macross (and my fic) are referred to as 
'Gladiators' in Robotech; the 'Spartans' of Robotech are 'Phalanx' in 
Macross.

You're right that this chapter could use a bit of fleshing out; I intend 
to go through the whole damn thing when it's done and give many other 
chapters that treatment.

Thanks for writing!

-- 
http://www.tailkinker.net                      ICQ# 66022322
"Love...this mad distemper that strikes down both beggar and 
king.  Never again!  Never!"  --Merlin



More information about the ffml mailing list